Wednesday, May 2, 2018

Melba Thomas - Tomato Farming on St. Helena Island

On 4/10/2018, Melba Thomas gave a presentation titled Tomato Farming on St. Helena IslandClick here to view the slideshow accompanying her presentation.

Tomatoes have been grown in South Carolina since the late 18th century according to “The Early History of the Tomato in South Carolina” an article published by the South Carolina Historical Society. The Sanders family has thought for years that Gustav (Gus) Sanders planted the first commercial tomato crop in 1909.  This information came from an article in the News and Courier, entitled Low-Country Gossip, by Chlotilde R. Martin and written during prohibition. However, Sharon Sanders found note of tomatoes being shipped out of Beaufort, SC in the spring of 1906. Gus Sanders was Ross Sanders grandfather. He was the tax collector for Beaufort County.  According to Ross, he was quite a land speculator. That is how he got all their property on the island.  An interesting side note is that he owned Dataw Island at one time. Doing some research for this paper, I learned that he bought several parcels of land in 1905 for about $1600 that make up Dataw now and sold them in 1907 for $10,000 excluding the cemetery which he gave to the Sam’s family. That has nothing to do with tomato farming but is just a fun tidbit.

This talk is limited to tomato production in Beaufort County since the 1920’s. Most of my research was done by talking to and taking notes from Mac and Don Sanders. They are 4th and 5th generation tomato farmers. I also learned a lot from local publications which have written articles on the Sanders family.
Farmers in the early part of this century grew a little bit of everything.  Tomatoes were only a small part of their operation. Ross Sanders talked about several packing houses in the Lobeco area that packed many different types of produce, tomatoes being one.  There were two packing houses, one in Port Royal and one in St. Helena that packed predominately tomatoes.  The packing house on St. Helena, which was close to the boat landing off Seaside Road was run by Gustav Sanders, great-grandfather to Mac Sanders.  Tomatoes were packed in wooden lugs or boxes, loaded on boats, and rowed to Port Royal.  At Port Royal, the tomatoes were loaded on railroad cars and shipped to the northeast markets. Ed Sanders started farming with his father in the late 20s. Other tomato farmers on St. Helena during this time had the names of Jones, Reager, and Hughes.

The depression took its toll on many of the farmers during this time.  In fact, during this time Mr. Hughes lost Cat Island because he trusted the banks to hold his money for a little while before he paid his creditors.  Gus Sanders lost a great deal of money during the bank failure but held on to his land.  However, it took him two years after the depression to raise enough money to plant another crop of tomatoes.
World War II brought change to the tomato industry as well as to the world.  Farmers started to get good money for produce including tomatoes.  Between World War II and the 60’s, tomato production grew to cover most of the county including from Hilton Head Island to Seabrook, in and around Beaufort and most of St. Helena. This boom in production saw names like Bishop, Trask, McCloud, Bellamy, Dempsey, Godley, Ulmer, Crosby, Taylor, and Neal.  Ross Sanders came to work on the farm in the late 1940’s. A man by the name of Max Lipman, who owned a brokerage house on the New York market, brought his six children to Beaufort during this time to purchase and later finance the production of tomatoes in Beaufort.  They later became the SixL’s Company, which is still here today.  This time frame saw the number of tomato packing houses grow to more than twelve.
In the early 60’s, conditions changed again.  Farming became more difficult to make a profit for several reasons.  There were horrific rains in the years 1962 through 1965, which flooded several people out.  There were several years of frost during this period that set the Sanders family back far enough to take ten years to work themselves out of debt.  High interest rates and tight money forced several farmers out.  Farmers had to turn to migrant labor to harvest the tremendous volume of tomatoes grown in the county.

The mid 70’s saw the change from ground to the plastic mulch culture used today.  This had several advantages, among them being better weed and moisture control, and less production loss due to ground born diseases. But, with these advantages came an increase in cost for production.  The Sanders family was one of the last farms to make this change.  They were getting similar money and similar yields with tomatoes being grown on the ground until the late 70’s.  Then one year, tomatoes grown on plastic brought a fifty-cent premium over ground tomatoes and they were forced to change.  Mac and Gray Sanders were working full time on the farm (4th generation and Clemson graduates) and helped to make this transition.  They spent a season repairing plastic that was blowing away all over the farm before they learned how to put it down effectively. 
 
In 1981, Shiparo, the last packing house to pack tomatoes for independent farmers closed its doors.  We have gone from over twelve packing houses in the 60’s to two left, Sanders and SixL’s.
In 1984 the switch was made to drip irrigation.  This time the Sanders farm was the first with this innovation.  This system of irrigation and fertilization allowed water and fertilizer to be applied directly to the plant’s root system.  With it came more controls than they knew what to do with.  Tomato yields increased greatly but the system is not forgiving to mistakes and the cost of production again increased.
In 1985, SixL’s, who were financing outside growers at the time started their company farm.  In 1996, SixL’s last outside grower left the company, leaving only the company farm.  This leaves us today with only two major tomato farms in the area, Seaside (Sanders) and SixL’s.

There are now less than eight hundred NET acres on St. Helena and Lobeco this year supplying two packing houses. Net acres mean the actual acreage taken up by rows of plants, not the ground between the rows or the ground at the end of the rows needed to turn the tractors and trucks around. It takes 600 acres to net 400 planting acres. Collectively they employ approximately thirty people year-round, approximately one hundred people during the tomato growing season, and greater than five hundred people during harvest.  At the end of harvest, at least one hundred people are employed to clean up the fields, that is to remove plastic and tomato string and stakes. All the extra help is housed at the farm’s expense.
Both packing houses together will ship over one and one half million twenty-five-pound boxes in approximately twenty-two working days and can ship over one hundred thousand boxes a day during peak days.  Estimate national consumption of tomatoes is approximately one million a day.  So, little Beaufort county is supplying its share. 

This is how it happens on Seaside Farm. In September and October, the Sanders start getting ready. In November plastic is put down over drip tubes; the plastic reflects the light to keep the insects away so there is less need for insecticides. Tomato seeds are ordered and sent to seed planting houses where the plants start to grow. They are then shipped by trucks to the farm where they are set by machines and workers between March 8 and March15. Rye grass has already been planted between the rows to protect the baby plants from the wind. Next, the stakes are driven in the rows between the plants by machines.  After the plants start to grow, strings are woven between and around the plants. A special crew of workers come in for the planting, staking, and stringing. Weather is always a factor during the growing process.  Planting started and stopped this year due to the cold snaps which thankfully have not injured the crop unlike the two years back to back in the 60’s when killing frosts happened on April 21st and April 20th. Of course, there is always the chance of too much rain, or rain during harvest or a myriad of other things to get past each year. The Sanders family has planted over one million plants this year on 400 net acres of 1000 acres total on the farm.  As one of the Sanders told me, I do not gamble at casinos, I gamble by being a farmer. The Sanders Family will ship over a half million boxes this year. 
The crop takes 88 – 90 days to mature. The tomatoes are harvested beginning on June 5, but the workers arrive on June 1 because the weather may be a factor. 

Approximately 300 people work in the fields picking and 150 work in the packing houses. The pickers in the field pick everything on a bush and place the tomatoes in plastic buckets that hold approximately 35-pounds each. They are then placed in plastic bins loaded on a truck that will take the 1000-pound load to the packing house where they are unloaded and washed in a bleach/water solution. They then proceed onto conveyor belts. There they will be sorted by size, color and grade. Only green tomatoes can be shipped, because handling red tomatoes isn’t feasible. They are then placed into cardboard boxes with glue on the top edges, packed by a special crew on pallets, and loaded onto waiting 18 wheelers by fork lifts.  One truck contains 20 pallets, each pallet holds 80, 25-pound boxes.  The trucks are driven across the street to the annex or ripening shed. There are 130 rooms in the annex. The pallets from a truck are placed in a room where they are cooled to 58 degrees and then gassed with ethylene gas (the same gas an apple gives off when ripening) This causes the tomatoes to turn pink. The buyers like to dictate the ripeness of their tomatoes. Claudio, an employee of the farm, determines when the room of tomatoes are the ripeness that the buyer desires.  They are loaded back on an eighteen-wheeler and sent to their destination somewhere east of the Mississippi riverMost end up in grocery stores and in salads in restaurants. None go to processing plants. They have also ended up in some rather exclusive places. Here is a great trivia question: what do the QE2 and Seaside Farm on St. Helena Island have in common?  Answer: The following used to be printed on the great ship’s menu: “Made with Seaside Farm Brand tomatoes.” Ross is quoted as saying “We had a great business with the Queens (QE2) going back and forth to Europe.  They’d pick up a truckload of our tomatoes and bring them up to New York.  They’d pay you a premium for good tomatoes.  We always took great pride in Seaside Farm tomatoes—top of the market.  It paid off when things got tough. We try to produce a higher quality tomato than anyone else because we’re a smaller farm than anyone else.” 

After the tomatoes are picked and shipped the crews then pull up the stakes and bale them to be reused for 5 years.  The plastic is pulled up and baled by a special machine to be recycled.  The irrigation hose is also removed and reused as possible.  The rows are then plowed under and ready for another year.  The crops are rotated to prevent soil borne diseases. 

Of the 400 acres planted in tomatoes, 150 acres are replanted in watermelons for a fall crop.  Watermelon plants are planted as soon as the old tomato plants are removed.

The ripe red tomatoes have always been discarded because they are too soft to be shipped.  They would be loaded onto dump trucks and taken back to somewhere on the farm and buried. I say the reds have always been discarded because this past year the 5th generation has come up with a plan to make use of a once discarded perfectly good commodity.  They decided to try their hand at making Bloody Mary mix. They hired a chef from Charleston and a chef from Savannah to put together a recipe with guidance from the family. They settled on a final recipe and had it made and bottled under the name of Seaside Grown in Charleston. They made an initial batch of three thousand bottles. It was such a success that they are planning to increase that to 150,000 bottles this year.  It was only marketed locally with mostly word of mouth. They will also be make a spicy variety named after Granddaddy Gus who I hear was quiet the spicy guy.  The plan is also to make salsa this year.  This year the products will be made and bottled on St. Helena at the co-op kitchen.  The plan is to take the product regionally. 

They just attended the Bloody Mary festival in Nashville (who knew there was such a thing) and placed 3rd overall.  They were the only bottled mix to ever place, as most mixes represented are made individually by bartenders or restaurants.  Each jar is made from two pounds of fresh tomatoes that have been cored and then combined with other ingredients to make the final product.  Most bottled bloody Mary mixes start with tomato paste and water.  This product, as you may have discovered, has lots of pulp and seeds.  Many customers use it to cook with or serve cold as gazpacho. 
Tomatoes have supported the Sanders family for four generations. Farming has provided a wonderful environment to raise families and they wish to continue as long as possible, but with more people in the family and the encroachment of people in the area they have to be innovative. 

Chemicals used in agriculture are not nearly as dangerous as people think. The farm has been draining directly into an estuary, for 3 generations, which was and still is pristine. However, with people getting their information from 60 minutes, there is a danger that regulations and the Clean Water Task force recommending retention ponds as a best management practice, could decrease the available land below profitable levels. Many say that we need to strike a balance between those who love the environment and those who love property rights. Mac was born in Beaufort as was his father, grandfather, and probably his great-grandfather. He says he has puff mud between his toes that he hopes he will never get out.  While there are people in Beaufort who love this area as much as he, there is no one who loves it more. Love for this environment and respect for property rights are not mutually exclusive. Being the daughter of a farmer, gives me much respect for this family and their practices.  I hope Beaufort County does not regulate them out of business. Farming in a sea of people can be difficult. The land is their most precious asset and, they would never do anything to diminish the value.